# Survey of Pacific Northwest public land managers science and values project, 2023 ## Dataset - **Database Code:** SS011 - **Title:** Survey of Pacific Northwest public land managers science and values project, 2023 - **Abstract:** This dataset records survey data about public land managers who work in Oregon and Washington (Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management, Fish and Wildlife Service, National Park Service, Oregon Department of Forestry, Washington Department of Natural Resources). Data was collected in 2023 via the online survey platform Qualtrics. Data collection is complete. The dataset includes measures of managers beliefs about 1) variable density thinning of mature growth forests, 2) salvage logging of burned areas, 3) translocation of plant species from hotter and drier seed zones to adapt to climate change. It includes how managers evaluate the usefulness of scientific evidence and the soundness of action prescriptions for each of the three management issues Respondents were randomly assigned to either receive long-term or short-term studies, and positive or negative results. The dataset includes measures of sense of belonging (how much managers believe they belong at their workplace) and measures of public support/public threat (how much they believe the public understands and supports the actions they take on the landscape). The dataset includes respondent agency. - **Keywords:** surveys; humans; human dimensions; attitudes and perceptions - **Temporal coverage:** 2023-05-01 to 2023-08-31 - **Principal Investigator:** Michael P. Nelson Jeremy T. Bruskotter ## Data Entities 1. Survey results of PNW public land managers science and values questionnaire ## Entity 1: Survey results of PNW public land managers science and values questionnaire ### Attribute list - **DBCODE** — varchar, enum FSDB Database Code - **SS011** — FSDB Database Study Code SS011 - **ENTITY** — numeric(1), range 1.0000 1.0000, number Entity number - **RID** — varchar, freetext Unique respondent identifier - **BELIEF_SALVAGE1** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.2 In general, I think salvage logging is a good management action. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_SALVAGE2** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.3 Salvage logging is an effective tool for reducing future fire severity. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_SALVAGE3** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.4 Salvage logging is necessary if we hope to reduce future fire risk. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_SALVAGE4** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.5 On my unit, salvage logging is a politically feasible management action. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_SALVAGE5** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.6 I think salvage logging aligns with the mission of my agency. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_SALVAGE6** — varchar, enum Survey Q4.7 The issue of salvage logging is relevant to my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN1** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.2 In general, I think thinning mature growth stands is a good management action. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN2** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.3 Thinning mature growth stands is an effective tool for creating forests with the structure and function of old growth. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN3** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.4 Variable density thinning is necessary if we hope to speed up the rate at which mature growth becomes old growth. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN4** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.5 On my unit, variable density thinning of mature growth stands is a politically feasible management action. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN5** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.6 I think thinning mature growth forests aligns with the mission of my agency. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_THIN6** — varchar, enum Survey Q5.7 The issue of variable density thinning of mature growth forests is relevant to my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS1** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.2 In general, I think translocation is a good response to climate change. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS2** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.3 Translocating plant species now is an effective way to adapt to climate change over the next 100 years. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS3** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.4 Translocating plant species now is necessary if we hope to maintain the structure and function of our ecosystems over the next 100 years. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS4** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.5 On my unit, translocating plant species is a politically feasible management action. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS5** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.7 I think it aligns with my agency's mission to translocate plant species in my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELIEF_TRANS6** — varchar, enum Survey Q6.7 The issue of translocation is relevant to my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE1** — varchar, enum Survery question 8.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on soil erosion - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE2** — varchar, enum Survey question 8.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on tree recruitment - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE3** — varchar, enum Survey question 8.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on smoke - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_PRO_SALVAGE** — varchar, enum Survey question 8.5-8.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_SALVAGE** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q8.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE1** — varchar, enum Survery question 9.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on soil erosion - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE2** — varchar, enum Survey question 9.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on tree recruitment - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE3** — varchar, enum Survey question 9.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on smoke - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE** — varchar, enum Survey question 9.5-9.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q9.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN1** — varchar, enum Survery question 10.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on transition - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN2** — varchar, enum Survey question 10.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on fire resistance - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN3** — varchar, enum Survey question 10.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on drought - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_ANTI_THIN** — varchar, enum Survey question 10.5-10.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_THIN** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q10.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_ST_PRO_THIN1** — varchar, enum Survery question 11.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on transition - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_THIN2** — varchar, enum Survey question 11.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on fire resistance - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_THIN3** — varchar, enum Survey question 11.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on drought - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_PRO_THIN** — varchar, enum Survey question 11.5-11.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_THIN** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q11.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS1** — varchar, enum Survery question 12.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on meadow - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS2** — varchar, enum Survey question 12.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on canopy cover - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS3** — varchar, enum Survey question 12.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on timber - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_PRO_TRANS** — varchar, enum Survey question 12.5-12.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_TRANS** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q12.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS1** — varchar, enum Survery question 13.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on meadow - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS2** — varchar, enum Survey question 13.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on canopy cover - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS3** — varchar, enum Survey question 13.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on timber - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_ST_ANTI_TRANS** — varchar, enum Survey question 13.5-13.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_TRANS** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q13.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE1** — varchar, enum Survery question 14.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on soil erosion - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE2** — varchar, enum Survey question 14.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on tree recruitment - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE3** — varchar, enum Survey question 14.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on smoke - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_PRO_SALVAGE** — varchar, enum Survey question 14.5-14.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_SALVAGE** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q14.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE1** — varchar, enum Survery question 15.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on soil erosion - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE2** — varchar, enum Survey question 15.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on tree recruitment - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE3** — varchar, enum Survey question 15.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on smoke - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE** — varchar, enum Survey question 15.5-15.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q15.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_PRO_THIN1** — varchar, enum Survery question 16.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on transition - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_THIN2** — varchar, enum Survey question 16.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on fire resistance - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_THIN3** — varchar, enum Survey question 16.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on drought - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_PRO_THIN** — varchar, enum Survey question 16.5-16.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_THIN** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q16.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN1** — varchar, enum Survery question 17.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on transition - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN2** — varchar, enum Survey question 17.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on fire resistance - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN3** — varchar, enum Survey question 17.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on drought - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_ANTI_THIN** — varchar, enum Survey question 17.5-17.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_THIN** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q17.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS1** — varchar, enum Survery question 18.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on meadow - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS2** — varchar, enum Survey question 18.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on canopy cover - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS3** — varchar, enum Survey question 18.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on timber - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_PRO_TRANS** — varchar, enum Survey question 18.5-18.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_TRANS** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q18.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS1** — varchar, enum Survery question 19.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on meadow - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS2** — varchar, enum Survey question 19.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on canopy cover - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS3** — varchar, enum Survey question 19.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on timber - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **SOUND_LT_ANTI_TRANS** — varchar, enum Survey question 19.5-19.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_TRANS** — varchar, freetext First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q19.8 (see entity 2 for full text) - **BELONG1** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.2 I get along with the people in my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELONG2** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.3 My coworkers have similar interests and hobbies as me. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELONG3** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.4 I am friends with my coworkers. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELONG4** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.5 I agree with the values of my agency. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELONG5** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.6 I agree with the priorities of my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **BELONG6** — varchar, enum Survey Q20.7 My supervisor and I have similar values. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT1** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.2 The public doesn't understand the objectives of my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT2_O** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.3 The public supports the decisions of my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT3** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.4 I am always prepared for someone in the public to legally challenge my unit's decisions. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT4_O** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.5 The public trusts the professional expertise of my unit. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT5** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.6 On my unit, we struggle to find decisions supported by most members of the public. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **THREAT6_O** — varchar, enum Survey Q21.7 My unit has a good relationship with the public. - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **AGENCY_STRING** — varchar, enum Survey Q22.2 Which agency do you currently work for? - **BLM** — Employed by Bureau of Land Management - **NPS** — Employed by National Park Service - **USFS** — Employed by US Forest Service - **ODF** — Employed by Oregon Department of Forestry - **WDNR** — Employed by Washington Department of Natural Resources - **USFWS** — Employed by US Fish and Wildlife Service - **OTHER** — For any other agency - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. - **REGION** — varchar, freetext Survey Q22.6 Level III Ecoregion of the Pacific Northwest where respondent works - **SALVAGE** — varchar, enum Experimental condition for all salvage logging evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) - **LT-ANTI** — For salvage questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For salvage questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For salvage questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For salvage questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the salvage block. - **THIN** — varchar, enum Experimental condition for all thinning evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) - **LT-ANTI** — For thinning questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For thinning questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For thinning questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For thinning questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the thin block. - **TRANS** — varchar, enum Experimental condition for all translocation evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) - **LT-ANTI** — For translocation questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For translocation questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For translocation questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For translocation questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the trans block. - **SALVAGE_ARGUMENT** — varchar, enum Code for which evidence statement was selected for the salvage action prescription (soundness) - **Smoke** — Respondent saw evidence statement about smoke for salvage soundness argument - **Soil Erosion** — Respondent saw evidence statement about soil erosion for salvage soundness argument - **Recruitment** — Respondent saw evidence statement about recruitment for salvage soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the salvage_argument question. - **THIN_ARGUMENT** — varchar, enum Code for which evidence statement was selected for the thinning action prescription (soundness) - **Transition** — Respondent saw evidence statement about transition for thinning soundness argument - **Drought Stress** — Respondent saw evidence statement about drought stress for thinning soundness argument - **Fire Resistance** — Respondent saw evidence statement about fire resistance for thinning soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the thin_argument question. - **TRANS_ARGUMENT** — varchar, enum Code for which evidence statement was selected for the translocation action prescription (soundness) - **Canopy Cover** — Respondent saw evidence statement about canopy cover for translocation soundness argument - **Timber** — Respondent saw evidence statement about timber for translocation soundness argument - **Meadow** — Respondent saw evidence statement about meadows for translocation soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the trans_argument question. ## Attribute Definitions **AGENCY_STRING** Survey Q22.2 Which agency do you currently work for? **BELIEF_SALVAGE1** Survey Q4.2 In general, I think salvage logging is a good management action. **BELIEF_SALVAGE2** Survey Q4.3 Salvage logging is an effective tool for reducing future fire severity. **BELIEF_SALVAGE3** Survey Q4.4 Salvage logging is necessary if we hope to reduce future fire risk. **BELIEF_SALVAGE4** Survey Q4.5 On my unit, salvage logging is a politically feasible management action. **BELIEF_SALVAGE5** Survey Q4.6 I think salvage logging aligns with the mission of my agency. **BELIEF_SALVAGE6** Survey Q4.7 The issue of salvage logging is relevant to my unit. **BELIEF_THIN1** Survey Q5.2 In general, I think thinning mature growth stands is a good management action. **BELIEF_THIN2** Survey Q5.3 Thinning mature growth stands is an effective tool for creating forests with the structure and function of old growth. **BELIEF_THIN3** Survey Q5.4 Variable density thinning is necessary if we hope to speed up the rate at which mature growth becomes old growth. **BELIEF_THIN4** Survey Q5.5 On my unit, variable density thinning of mature growth stands is a politically feasible management action. **BELIEF_THIN5** Survey Q5.6 I think thinning mature growth forests aligns with the mission of my agency. **BELIEF_THIN6** Survey Q5.7 The issue of variable density thinning of mature growth forests is relevant to my unit. **BELIEF_TRANS1** Survey Q6.2 In general, I think translocation is a good response to climate change. **BELIEF_TRANS2** Survey Q6.3 Translocating plant species now is an effective way to adapt to climate change over the next 100 years. **BELIEF_TRANS3** Survey Q6.4 Translocating plant species now is necessary if we hope to maintain the structure and function of our ecosystems over the next 100 years. **BELIEF_TRANS4** Survey Q6.5 On my unit, translocating plant species is a politically feasible management action. **BELIEF_TRANS5** Survey Q6.7 I think it aligns with my agency's mission to translocate plant species in my unit. **BELIEF_TRANS6** Survey Q6.7 The issue of translocation is relevant to my unit. **BELONG1** Survey Q20.2 I get along with the people in my unit. **BELONG2** Survey Q20.3 My coworkers have similar interests and hobbies as me. **BELONG3** Survey Q20.4 I am friends with my coworkers. **BELONG4** Survey Q20.5 I agree with the values of my agency. **BELONG5** Survey Q20.6 I agree with the priorities of my unit. **BELONG6** Survey Q20.7 My supervisor and I have similar values. **DBCODE** FSDB Database Code **ENTITY** Entity number **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q15.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_THIN** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q17.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_LT_ANTI_TRANS** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q19.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_SALVAGE** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q14.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_THIN** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q16.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_LT_PRO_TRANS** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q18.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q9.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_THIN** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q10.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_ANTI_TRANS** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q13.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_SALVAGE** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q8.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_THIN** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q11.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **EXPLAIN_ST_PRO_TRANS** First 254 characters of open-ended response to Q12.8 (see entity 2 for full text) **REGION** Survey Q22.6 Level III Ecoregion of the Pacific Northwest where respondent works **RID** Unique respondent identifier **SALVAGE** Experimental condition for all salvage logging evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) **SALVAGE_ARGUMENT** Code for which evidence statement was selected for the salvage action prescription (soundness) **SOUND_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE** Survey question 15.5-15.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" **SOUND_LT_ANTI_THIN** Survey question 17.5-17.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" **SOUND_LT_ANTI_TRANS** Survey question 19.5-19.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" **SOUND_LT_PRO_SALVAGE** Survey question 14.5-14.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" **SOUND_LT_PRO_THIN** Survey question 16.5-16.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" **SOUND_LT_PRO_TRANS** Survey question 18.5-18.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" **SOUND_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE** Survey question 9.5-9.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" **SOUND_ST_ANTI_THIN** Survey question 10.5-10.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" **SOUND_ST_ANTI_TRANS** Survey question 13.5-13.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" **SOUND_ST_PRO_SALVAGE** Survey question 8.5-8.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "salvage_argument" **SOUND_ST_PRO_THIN** Survey question 11.5-11.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "thin_argument" **SOUND_ST_PRO_TRANS** Survey question 12.5-12.8; argument based on one evidence statement, see attribute "trans_argument" **THIN** Experimental condition for all thinning evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) **THIN_ARGUMENT** Code for which evidence statement was selected for the thinning action prescription (soundness) **THREAT1** Survey Q21.2 The public doesn't understand the objectives of my unit. **THREAT2_O** Survey Q21.3 The public supports the decisions of my unit. **THREAT3** Survey Q21.4 I am always prepared for someone in the public to legally challenge my unit's decisions. **THREAT4_O** Survey Q21.5 The public trusts the professional expertise of my unit. **THREAT5** Survey Q21.6 On my unit, we struggle to find decisions supported by most members of the public. **THREAT6_O** Survey Q21.7 My unit has a good relationship with the public. **TRANS** Experimental condition for all translocation evidence statements and action prescriptions (soundness) **TRANS_ARGUMENT** Code for which evidence statement was selected for the translocation action prescription (soundness) **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE1** Survery question 15.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on soil erosion **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE2** Survey question 15.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on tree recruitment **USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE3** Survey question 15.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-salvage on smoke **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN1** Survery question 17.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on transition **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN2** Survey question 17.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on fire resistance **USE_LT_ANTI_THIN3** Survey question 17.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-thin on drought **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS1** Survery question 19.2 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on meadow **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS2** Survey question 19.3 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on canopy cover **USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS3** Survey question 19.4 on usefulness, long-term, anti-translocation on timber **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE1** Survery question 14.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on soil erosion **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE2** Survey question 14.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on tree recruitment **USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE3** Survey question 14.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-salvage on smoke **USE_LT_PRO_THIN1** Survery question 16.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on transition **USE_LT_PRO_THIN2** Survey question 16.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on fire resistance **USE_LT_PRO_THIN3** Survey question 16.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-thin on drought **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS1** Survery question 18.2 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on meadow **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS2** Survey question 18.3 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on canopy cover **USE_LT_PRO_TRANS3** Survey question 18.4 on usefulness, long-term, pro-translocation on timber **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE1** Survery question 9.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on soil erosion **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE2** Survey question 9.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on tree recruitment **USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE3** Survey question 9.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-salvage on smoke **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN1** Survery question 10.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on transition **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN2** Survey question 10.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on fire resistance **USE_ST_ANTI_THIN3** Survey question 10.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-thin on drought **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS1** Survery question 13.2 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on meadow **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS2** Survey question 13.3 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on canopy cover **USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS3** Survey question 13.4 on usefulness, short-term, anti-translocation on timber **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE1** Survery question 8.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on soil erosion **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE2** Survey question 8.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on tree recruitment **USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE3** Survey question 8.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-salvage on smoke **USE_ST_PRO_THIN1** Survery question 11.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on transition **USE_ST_PRO_THIN2** Survey question 11.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on fire resistance **USE_ST_PRO_THIN3** Survey question 11.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-thin on drought **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS1** Survery question 12.2 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on meadow **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS2** Survey question 12.3 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on canopy cover **USE_ST_PRO_TRANS3** Survey question 12.4 on usefulness, short-term, pro-translocation on timber ## Enumerated Domains ### DBCODE - **SS011** — FSDB Database Study Code SS011 ### BELIEF_SALVAGE1 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_SALVAGE2 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_SALVAGE3 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_SALVAGE4 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_SALVAGE5 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_SALVAGE6 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN1 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN2 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN3 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN4 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN5 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_THIN6 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS1 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS2 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS3 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS4 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS5 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELIEF_TRANS6 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_SALVAGE3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_PRO_SALVAGE - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_ANTI_SALVAGE - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_THIN1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_THIN2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_THIN3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_ANTI_THIN - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_THIN1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_THIN2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_THIN3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_PRO_THIN - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_TRANS1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_TRANS2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_PRO_TRANS3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_PRO_TRANS - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_ST_ANTI_TRANS3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_ST_ANTI_TRANS - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_SALVAGE3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_PRO_SALVAGE - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_ANTI_SALVAGE - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_THIN1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_THIN2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_THIN3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_PRO_THIN - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_THIN1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_THIN2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_THIN3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_ANTI_THIN - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_TRANS1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_TRANS2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_PRO_TRANS3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_PRO_TRANS - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS1 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS2 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### USE_LT_ANTI_TRANS3 - **-2** — Not at all useful - **-1** — Slightly useful - **** — Moderately useful - **1** — Very useful - **2** — Extremely useful - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SOUND_LT_ANTI_TRANS - **-2** — Not at all sound - **-1** — Slightly sound - **** — Moderately sound - **1** — Very sound - **2** — Extremely sound - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG1 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG2 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG3 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG4 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG5 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### BELONG6 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT1 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT2_O - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT3 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT4_O - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT5 - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### THREAT6_O - **-2** — Strongly Disagree - **-1** — Somewhat disagree - **** — Neither agree nor disagree - **1** — Somewhat agree - **2** — Strongly Agree - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### AGENCY_STRING - **BLM** — Employed by Bureau of Land Management - **NPS** — Employed by National Park Service - **USFS** — Employed by US Forest Service - **ODF** — Employed by Oregon Department of Forestry - **WDNR** — Employed by Washington Department of Natural Resources - **USFWS** — Employed by US Fish and Wildlife Service - **OTHER** — For any other agency - **NA** — Respondent did not provide a response to the question. Respondent may have skipped the question or did not see that part of the survey. ### SALVAGE - **LT-ANTI** — For salvage questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For salvage questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For salvage questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For salvage questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the salvage block. ### THIN - **LT-ANTI** — For thinning questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For thinning questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For thinning questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For thinning questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the thin block. ### TRANS - **LT-ANTI** — For translocation questions, the respondent received long-term, negative evidence - **ST-PRO** — For translocation questions, the respondent received short-term, positive evidence - **ST-ANTI** — For translocation questions, the respondent received short-term, negative evidence - **LT-PRO** — For translocation questions, the respondent received long-term, positive evidence - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the trans block. ### SALVAGE_ARGUMENT - **Smoke** — Respondent saw evidence statement about smoke for salvage soundness argument - **Soil Erosion** — Respondent saw evidence statement about soil erosion for salvage soundness argument - **Recruitment** — Respondent saw evidence statement about recruitment for salvage soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the salvage_argument question. ### THIN_ARGUMENT - **Transition** — Respondent saw evidence statement about transition for thinning soundness argument - **Drought Stress** — Respondent saw evidence statement about drought stress for thinning soundness argument - **Fire Resistance** — Respondent saw evidence statement about fire resistance for thinning soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the thin_argument question. ### TRANS_ARGUMENT - **Canopy Cover** — Respondent saw evidence statement about canopy cover for translocation soundness argument - **Timber** — Respondent saw evidence statement about timber for translocation soundness argument - **Meadow** — Respondent saw evidence statement about meadows for translocation soundness argument - **NA** — Respondent did not proceed far enough through the survey to be assigned an experimental condition for the trans_argument question.