SP008: Effect of thinning pole stands on soil processes in southern Oregon, central Coast Range, and central western Cascades of Oregon (1994-1995 BLM Study)
Notice
"As Is" Basis: All content, including maps and forecasts, is provided without warranties. Users are advised to independently verify critical information.
Citation
Griffiths, R. 2013. Effect of thinning pole stands on soil processes in southern Oregon, central Coast Range, and central western Cascades of Oregon (1994-1995 BLM Study) Long-Term Ecological Research Andrews Forest LTER Site. [Database]. Available: https://andrewsforest-stage.forestry.oregonstate.edu/data/fsdb-data-catalog/SP008 Accessed 2026-05-10.
Abstract
This study was conducted in different regions to determine if climatic regimes alter the effects of thinning pole stands. Forest managers are currently faced with increasingly complex demands in designing sulvicultural approaches that fulfill the need to maintain and in some cases, enhance forest health. As mature and old-growth forests with their high degree of structural heterogeneity are replaced by younger plantations with much simpler structure, there is concern that key habitat components are being lost for a number of plants and animals. A silviculture technique that could be used to increase the structural complexity of young stands to thin them; encouraging the development of higher structural complexity. The main purposes of this study is to determine how thinning pole stands influence below-ground processes. The central research question was whether or not this manipulation brings soil characteristics closer to those found in old-growth forests; in essence, accelerating the onset of old-growth-like characteristics via forest management.
Coverage
Temporal coverage: 1994-01-01 to 1996-01-01
Geographic coverage: N/A
Bounds: W N/A, E N/A, N N/A, S N/A
Purpose
No purpose entries listed in this EML file.
Project
Title: Long-Term Ecological Research
Personnel
-
Sherri L. Johnson - Principal Investigator US Forest Service ;Pacific NW Research Station ;3200 SW Jefferson Way, Corvallis, OR, 97331, USAPhone: 541-758-7771Email: sherri.johnson2@usda.gov, sherri.johnson@oregonstate.edu
-
Julia A. Jones - Principal Investigator Oregon State University;Department of Geosciences; Wilkinson Hall 104, Corvallis, OR, 97331-5506, USAPhone: (541) 737-1224Email: Julia.Jones@oregonstate.edu, geojulia@comcast.netORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0001-9429-8925
-
Matthew G Betts - Principal Investigator Department of Forest Ecosystems and Society; 201E Richardson Hall; College of Forestry; Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, 97331Phone: (541) 737-3841Email: matt.betts@oregonstate.edu
-
Michael P. Nelson - Principal Investigator Department of Forest Ecosystems and Society; 201K Richarson Hall; College of Forestry; Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, 97331Phone: 541-737-9221Email: mpnelson@oregonstate.eduORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6917-4752
-
David Bell - Principal Investigator Email: david.bell@usda.gov, david.bell@oregonstate.edu
Abstract
- The H.J. Andrews Experimental Forest is a living laboratory that provides unparalleled opportunities for the study of forest and stream ecosystems in the central Cascade Range of Oregon. Since 1980, as a part of the National Science Foundation Long Term Ecological Research (NSF-LTER) program, the Andrews Experimental Forest has become a leader in the analysis of forest and stream ecosystem dynamics.
- Long-term field experiments and measurement programs have focused on climate dynamics, streamflow, water quality, and vegetation succession. Currently researchers are working to develop concepts and tools needed to predict effects of natural disturbance, land use, and climate change on ecosystem structure, function, and species composition.
- The Andrews Experimental Forest is administered cooperatively by the USDA Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, Oregon State University and the Willamette National Forest. Funding for the research program comes from the National Science Foundation (NSF), US Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, Oregon State University, and other sources.
Funding
Data were provided by the HJ Andrews Experimental Forest research program, funded by the National Science Foundation's Long-Term Ecological Research Program (DEB 2025755), US Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, and Oregon State University. National Science Foundation: DEB1440409
Study Area Description
-
Long-Term Ecological Research The Andrews Forest is situated in the western Cascade Range of Oregon, and covers the entire 15,800-acre (6400-ha) drainage basin of Lookout Creek. Elevation ranges from 1350 to 5340 feet (410 to 1630 m). Broadly representative of the rugged mountainous landscape of the Pacific Northwest, the Andrews Forest contains excellent examples of the region's conifer forests and associated wildlife and stream ecosystems. These forests are among the tallest and most productive in the world, with tree heights of often greater than 250 ft (75 m). Streams are steep, cold and clean, providing habitat for numerous aquatic organisms.
Associated Party
-
Robert P. Griffiths
Role: Principal InvestigatorOregon State University;Dept. of Forest Science;321 Richardson Hall, Corvallis, OR, 97331-5752, USAPhone: (541) 737-6559Email: bbgriff@peak.org, griff@for.orst.edu
-
Robert P. Griffiths
Role: AbstractorOregon State University;Dept. of Forest Science;321 Richardson Hall, Corvallis, OR, 97331-5752, USAPhone: (541) 737-6559Email: bbgriff@peak.org, griff@for.orst.edu
-
Robert P. Griffiths
Role: CreatorOregon State University;Dept. of Forest Science;321 Richardson Hall, Corvallis, OR, 97331-5752, USAPhone: (541) 737-6559Email: bbgriff@peak.org, griff@for.orst.edu
Contact
-
Information Manager
Andrews Forest LTER Program, US Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, 3200 SW Jefferson Way, Corvallis, OR, 97331Email: hjaweb@fsl.orst.edu
-
Donald L. Henshaw
Pacific Northwest Research Station; Corvallis Forestry Sciences Lab; 3200 SW Jefferson Way, Corvallis, Oregon, 97331Email: hja_admin@fsl.orst.edu
Publisher
-
Andrews Forest LTER Site
Role: PublisherForest Ecosystems and Society Department in Forestry, Oregon State University, 201K Richardson Hall, Corvallis, OR, 97331-5752Phone: (541) 737-8480Email: lterweb@fsl.orst.edu
Study Description
This study was conducted in different regions to determine if climatic regimes alter the effects of thinning pole stands. Forest managers are currently faced with increasingly complex demands in designing sulvicultural approaches that fulfill the need to maintain and in some cases, enhance forest health. As mature and old-growth forests with their high degree of structural heterogeneity are replaced by younger plantations with much simpler structure, there is concern that key habitat components are being lost for a number of plants and animals. A silviculture technique that could be used to increase the structural complexity of young stands to thin them; encouraging the development of higher structural complexity. The main purposes of this study is to determine how thinning pole stands influence below-ground processes. The central research question was whether or not this manipulation brings soil characteristics closer to those found in old-growth forests; in essence, accelerating the onset of old-growth-like characteristics via forest management. Field Methods - SP008
Methods
Method Steps
Field Methods - SP008
- Mineral soil samples were collected with a trowel to a depth of 10 cm and transported to the laboratory in an ice chest. Soils were stored at 15°C until the initiation of the analyses which was within 16 h of their receipt.
- Field forest floor respiration rates, soil temperature, and litter depth were all measured at the study sites. The 24 h forest floor respiration was measured using a standard soda-lime technique (Edwards, 1982) . At the end of the incubation period, a 10 mL headspace gas sample was removed from the incubation chambers before the soda-lime jars were removed. Headspace samples from sealed controls were used to subtract out ambient CO concentrations at the site prior to initiation of the incubation period. Headspace CO that was not absorbed by the soda lime during the incubation period was added to the total CO adsorbed into the soda lime. Headspace CO concentrations were measured on a Hewlett Packard model 5890 gas chromatograph fitted with Hewlett Packard model 3396 integrator. The GC was fitted with a flame ionization detector and a methanizer in series. The integrator was calibrated using known gas standards and the external calibration method.
Laboratory Methods - SP008
- The other soil characteristics measured in this study were: soil organic matter, laboratory respiration, exchangeable ammonium, mineralizable nitrogen, water extractable organic carbon, denitrification potential, pH, bulk density, and moisture.
- In preparation for laboratory analysis, all soils except those used in the water extractable organic carbon measurements were sieved through a 2-mm sieve. Soil organic matter was measured by loss-on-ignition at 550°C for 6 h following oven drying at 100°C. Laboratory respiration rates were measured by adding 5 g field moist soil to a 25 mL Erlenmyer flask. After being sealed with a serum bottle cap, the flasks were incubated at 24°C for one hr. Zero-time headspace-CO concentration measurements were made after an initial 1 h preincubation period. Flasks were subsequently incubated for 2 h at 24 °C and the headspace analyzed again for CO. CO concentrations were assayed with a GC as described above. In the HO respiration experiments, the same procedure was followed as for laboratory respiration rates except 2.0 mL of sterile HO was added to the soils in the flasks; for SIR, 2 mL of sterile 1 mM glucose was added to the soils.
- Exchangeable NH concentration was determined by shaking 10 g field-moist soil with 50 mL 2 M KCl for 1 h (Keeney, 1982). After adding 0.3 mL 10 M NaOH to the slurry, NH concentration was measured with a Orion model 95-12 ammonium electrode (Orion Research Inc. Boston, Ma, USA). Mineralizable N was measured using the waterlogged technique (Keeney, 1982). Ten g of field-moist soil was added to 53 mL of distilled water in a 20 x 125 mm screw cap test tube and incubating at 40°C. After 7 days, 53 ml of 4 M KCl was added to the slurry and NH concentration was determined with the ammonium electrode. Mineralizable N was calculated from the difference between initial and final NH concentrations.
- Water extractable organic carbon (DOC) determinations were made using a Dormann Carbon Analyzer. DOC extractions were made on nonsieved samples. Five g of wet weight soil were slurried with 15 ml of water in 100 mL serum bottles and shaken for one hour at 24°C. Subsamples of the resulting slurry were centrifuged at 13,600 x g for 5 min. on a microfuge (Sorvall model MC12 V). Water-only blanks were run concomitantly to subtract out background organic carbon levels. Supernatants were extracted from the centrifuge tubes and frozen until analyzed.
- Just before analyzing the samples, they were thawed and vortexed to suspend the precipitate. A series of experiments conducted with identical subsamples had the following treatments: (1) not frozen, (2) frozen with vortexing, and (3) frozen without vortexing. It was found that treatments 1 and 2 produced the same result therefore we concluded that the freezing and subsequent resuspension did not bias the resulting measurements.
- Denitrification potential was measured using a method similar that used by Groffman and Tiedje (1989). Each reaction vessel (25 mL Erlenmeyer flask) contained 5 g of less than 2mm, field-moist soil. The flask was sealed with a rubber serum bottle stopper and purged with Ar to displace O in the headspace. After purging with argon, 2 mL of a 1mM solution of glucose and NO was added to the flask which were incubated at 25°C for one hr. This preincubation period was used because time series experiments on representative soils showed a lag in NO production during this period. The same experiments have shown linear NO production rates during the following 2-4 hr. After the preincubation period, 0.5 mL of headspace gas was removed from the reaction vessel and injected into a gas chromatograph fitted with an electron capture detector (Hewlett Packard model 5890 GC fitted with Hewlett Packard model 3396 integrator).
- Another headspace NO analysis was made after an additional two hr incubation at 25°C. The net NO released over this 2 h period was used to estimate NO production rates. Acetylene was not routinely added to the headspace to prevent the conversion of NO to N because randomly selected samples (10% of the total) were also assayed with a 10% acetylene atmosphere. There were no significant differences between NO production rates with and without acetylene.
- Soil pH was measured in 1:10 (soil: distilled water) slurries of oven-dried (100°C) soil. These slurries were shaken for 1 h prior to reading pH values with Sigma model E4753 electrode.
Sampling
Study Extent
- Sampling frequency: once only
Sampling Description
- Each of the three forest types; oldgrowth, thinned pole and pole stands (OG. T, and P) used in this study were organized into triads to reduce confounding elements while comparing treatments. Individual sites within each triad were matched by elevation, aspect and proximity. Three triads were analyzed in each of the three regions. At each site, soil samples were collected to a depth of 10 cm every 5 m along a 250 m transect.
Software
No software entries listed in this EML file.
Keywords
- LTER controlled vocabulary: soil chemistry (theme), soil respiration (theme), respiration (theme), disturbance (theme), inorganic nutrients (theme), organic matter (theme), soil organic matter (theme), forests (theme)
- Andrews Experimental Forest site thesaurus: Long-Term Ecological Research (LTER) (theme), conifers (theme)
- LTER core research areas: disturbance (theme), inorganic nutrients (theme), organic matter (theme)
Taxonomic Hierarchy
No taxonomic hierarchy listed in this EML file.
Data Entities
| # | Entity | Metadata | Data |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
SP00801
SP00801 Data for BLM thinned pole stand study: |
METADATA | DATA |
Metadata
SP00801 - SP00801
Object name: SP00801.csv
Records: 1350
Attributes: 23
File size: 160995 byte
Checksum (MD5): 7cc56880bee641bdba6331b3715eff97
Format: headers=1, recordDelimiter=\r\n, fieldDelimiter=,, quoteCharacter=", orientation=column
Constraints (2)
-
primaryKey: PRIMARY SP00801.DISTANCE, SP00801.LOCAT, SP00801.REGION, SP00801.TREAT, SP00801.TRIAD
-
notNullConstraint: NOTNULL SP00801.DISTANCE, SP00801.FORMAT, SP00801.LOCAT, SP00801.REGION, SP00801.STCODE, SP00801.TREAT, SP00801.TRIAD
Attributes (23)
STCODE - char(10) (nominal)
ID: SP00801.STCODE
FSDB Database Study code
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Code definitions (1)
-
SP008
FSDB Database Study code SP008
FORMAT - numeric(1,0) (interval)
ID: SP00801.FORMAT
Format number
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: number
Precision: 1.000000
Numeric domain: type=natural, min=1.0000 (exclusive=false), max=1.0000 (exclusive=false)
REGION - char(6) (nominal)
ID: SP00801.REGION
Region
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Code definitions (3)
-
CA
Cascades
-
CO
Coastal
-
SO
Southern oregon
TREAT - char(7) (nominal)
ID: SP00801.TREAT
Treatment type
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Code definitions (3)
-
OG
Oldgrowth
-
P
Pole stand
-
T
Thinned pole stand
TRIAD - numeric(1,0) (interval)
ID: SP00801.TRIAD
Triad number
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: number
Precision: 1
Numeric domain: type=natural, min=1.0000 (exclusive=false), max=3.0000 (exclusive=false)
LOCAT - char(9) (nominal)
ID: SP00801.LOCAT
Position along transect where sample is taken, 1 = start of transect
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
DISTANCE - numeric(8,0) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.DISTANCE
Distance in meters from beginning of transect
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: meters
Precision: 1.000000
Numeric domain: type=whole, min=0.0000 (exclusive=false), max=245.0000 (exclusive=false)
HEADSP - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.HEADSP
Concentration of CO2 in chamber at end of incubation time
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: percent
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.0070 (exclusive=false), max=0.3720 (exclusive=false)
TOTALCO2 - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.TOTALCO2
Amount of CO2 released from forest floor per sq. meter per day
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: grams per square meter per day
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=-0.4400 (exclusive=false), max=4.3340 (exclusive=false)
LABRESP - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.LABRESP
Co2 released from soils incubated at 15 deg C with no amendments (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micromoles per gram per hour
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=-0.0690 (exclusive=false), max=3.5600 (exclusive=false)
H2ORESP - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.H2ORESP
CO2 released from soils incubated at 15 deg C amended with water (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micromoles per gram per hour
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=-1.1440 (exclusive=false), max=2.7030 (exclusive=false)
SIR - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.SIR
CO2 released from soils incubated at 15 deg C amended with 1 um glucose (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micromoles per gram per hour
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=-1.8280 (exclusive=false), max=4.0130 (exclusive=false)
LITTER - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.LITTER
Letter depth
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: centimeters
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.0000 (exclusive=false), max=190.0000 (exclusive=false)
SOILTEMP - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.SOILTEMP
Soil temperature
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: degrees Celsius
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=6.0000 (exclusive=false), max=19.5000 (exclusive=false)
BULKDENSIT - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.BULKDENSIT
Bulk density
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: grams per gram
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.0000 (exclusive=false), max=1.3390 (exclusive=false)
PH - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.PH
pH
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: pH units
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=3.7300 (exclusive=false), max=7.5900 (exclusive=false)
FDW - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.FDW
Wt fraction dry/wet wt soil
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: number
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.1480 (exclusive=false), max=0.9930 (exclusive=false)
PERMOI - numeric(8,2) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.PERMOI
Percent moisture (wet-dry/dry)x100
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: percent
Precision: 0.010000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.7000 (exclusive=false), max=575.6800 (exclusive=false)
SOM - numeric(8,2) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.SOM
Percent soil organic matter in mineral soil (by compustion at 550 c)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: percent
Precision: 0.010000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=5.2400 (exclusive=false), max=95.4300 (exclusive=false)
EXTRAMM - numeric(9,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.EXTRAMM
Concentration of ammoniom extracted with 2m KCl (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micrograms per gram
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.0000 (exclusive=false), max=30.3200 (exclusive=false)
MIN_N - numeric(8,1) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.MIN_N
Cencentration ammoniom after incubaton at 40 deg C for 7 days (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micrograms per gram
Precision: 0.100000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=1.4000 (exclusive=false), max=451.1000 (exclusive=false)
DOC - numeric(8,1) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.DOC
Dissolved organic carbon extracted from soils (dry weight basis)
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: micrograms per gram
Precision: 0.100000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=0.0000 (exclusive=false), max=15.2000 (exclusive=false)
DENI - numeric(8,3) (ratio)
ID: SP00801.DENI
Denitrification potential on a dry weight basis
Type system: Microsoft SQL Server 2008
Unit: nanomoles per gram per hour
Precision: 0.001000
Numeric domain: type=real, min=-2.5700 (exclusive=false), max=61.6400 (exclusive=false)
Units
| grams per gram | g/g | massPerMass | gramPerGram | gramPerGram | 1 | grams per gram (often in terms of dry weight) |
| nanomoles per gram per hour | nmol/g*hr | amountOfSubstanceWeightFlux | nanomolePerGramPerHour | molePerKilogramPerSecond | 0.0036 | nanomoles per gram per hour |
| meters | m | length | meter | meter | 1 | meter; SI unit of length |
| centimeters | cm | length | centimeter | meter | 0.01 | centimeters; .01 meters |
| micrograms per gram | ug/g | massPerMass | microgramPerGram | gramPerGram | 0.000001 | micrograms per gram |
| pH units | ph | undefined | pH | unknown | N/A | Scale used for pH measurements |
| micromoles per gram per hour | umol/g*hr | amountOfSubstanceWeightFlux | micromolePerGramPerHour | molePerKilogramPerSecond | 3.6 | micromoles per g per hour |
| percent | % | dimensionless | number | dimensionless | 100 | percent; a number |
| degrees Celsius | deg c | temperature | celsiusDegree | kelvin | 1 | Degrees Celsius; a common unit of temperature; constantToSI=273.18 |
| grams per square meter per day | g/m2*day | arealMassDensityRate | gramPerMeterSquaredPerDay | kilogramPerMeterSquaredPerSecond | 86.4 | grams per square meter per day |
| number | number | dimensionless | number | dimensionless | 1 | dimensionless number, i.e., ratio, count |
Intellectual Rights
Data Use Agreement:
The re-use of scientific data has the potential to greatly increase communication, collaboration and synthesis within and among disciplines, and thus is fostered, supported and encouraged. This Data Set is released under the Creative Commons license CC BY "Attribution" (see: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Creative Commons license CC BY - Attribution is a license that allows others to distribute, remix, tweak, and build upon your work (even commercially), as long as you are credited for the original creation. This license accommodates maximum dissemination and use of licensed materials.
It is considered professional conduct and an ethical obligation to acknowledge the work of other scientists. The Data User is asked to provide attribution of the original work if this data package is shared in whole or by individual parts or used in the derivation of other products. A recommended citation is provided for each Data Set in the Andrews LTER data catalog (see: http://andlter.forestry.oregonstate.edu/data/catalog/datacatalog.aspx). A generic citation is also provided for this Data Set on the website https://portal.edirepository.org in the summary metadata page. Data Users are thus strongly encouraged to consider consultation, collaboration and/or co-authorship with the Data Set Creator.
While substantial efforts are made to ensure the accuracy of data and associated documentation, complete accuracy of data sets cannot be guaranteed and all data are made available "as is." The Data User should be aware, however, that data are updated periodically and it is the responsibility of the Data User to check for new versions of the data. The data authors and the repository where these data were obtained shall not be liable for damages resulting from any use or misinterpretation of the data.
General acknowledgement: Data were provided by the HJ Andrews Experimental Forest research program, funded by the National Science Foundation's Long-Term Ecological Research Program (DEB 2025755), US Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, and Oregon State University.
Licensed
License: N/A
Maintenance
Maintenance update frequency: notPlanned
Description
- An update history is logged and maintained with each new version of every dataset.
Change History
-
Version1 (1999-04-09) Original metadata creation.
-
Version2 (2002-02-27) Metadata restructured and moved into SQLServer metadata database LTERMETA. Data moved into SQLServer database FSDBDATA.
-
Version7 (2013-12-17) Converted STCODE to enum, ran QC, recreate CSV file for new delimiter for upload to PASTA.